Pakistan would not have been born - Instablogs
Pakistan would not have been born
Ashish Banerjee , Gurgaon: May 19 2009
Made Popular May 20 2009
India :

Pakistan would not have been born

On the eve of the Republic Day Celebrations, the bone of contention keeps coming on the mind that what would have happened if persons like Sonia Gandhi had been at the helm of affairs at the time of India’s Independence. Wouldn’t she welcome Jinnah to become India’s Prime Minister to save India from being divided and rescued us from the agony, dismay and horror of breaking the country into three pieces. Happening so, Pakistan would not have born.

In reality, this didn’t happen 61 years back. Nehrus and Patels did not have such generosity to invite their erstwhile fellow Congressman Mohd. Ali Jinnah and ask him to rule the united India. Had that been done, no British acumen could have broken apart the country during the historic moment. But that did not happen, and Pakistan had been born with an unquenchable hatred feeling for India.

Allowing Jinnah to become the first Prime Minister of India may perhaps sound ridiculous for many. But an independent and intellectual thought to this may find few takers, if not all.

Most Muslims and Pakistanis in particular, still conceive candidly that the Hindus would never have given up leadership to a Muslim ever for a combined India by the sheer majority of population. In that scenario, the Indian Constitution would have been written in a more diligent way to win the hearts of all sections of the society.

The head of the government, the Prime Minister would be rotating. The head of the state, the President and the head of the judiciary, the Chief Justice of Supreme court would have more powers and also rotate to accommodate different groups. Had it been so, its people would have been contented with its independence, and India would have become more powerful, self-sufficient and independent than any other nation in the world. We would have thus seen an equal representation of all society in every field which would have been a yardstick for other nations of the world.

If that had happened, the subcontinent, a single nation would have been a terror free, economic and military super power, decisive and more respected throughout the world by the end of eighties, which at present is not.

It would then surely keep an edge over China, our irrepressible neighbor, from all fronts because of its democratic lineage and western linguistic advantage.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Shivangi Singh
New Delhi, India
Pakistan is a reality now and i think its high time that we forget the painful story of partition.Its time to move on. Thinking that, had sonia gandhi been at the helm of affairs at time would have meant no partition is a wishful thinking, nothing more.
1 Stars
Bin
Meerut, India
I think you are right. We can't go back in the past and change what happened. Its better to move ahead with the new plans and a will to execute them.
1 Stars
Avadhut
Calicut, India
Shivangi

No doubt Pakistan is a reality. But we can’t neglect the causes of the partition, rather we should dissect these causes again and again so that we could avoid any further partition of the country based on religious lines.
1 Stars
Hiten
Ranchi, India
The root cause of the issue was that neither Jinnah, nor Nehru was ready to compromise on being the 1st Prime Minister. Both of them wanted this tag in front of their names. As a result, massive massacre took place along with the partition of the country.
1 Stars
Garima
Nagpur, India
Politician is a politician by the end of the day. They ought to see their personal benefit rather than nation as a whole.
1 Stars
Gaurav
Banglore, India
And we all know that Nehru and Indira Gandhi were power thirsty and always wanted to rule India.
1 Stars
Muhammad
Islamabad, Pakistan
People of pakistan would still have been in loss. There we would not have got our rights and here our govt doesn't know how to protect them.
1 Stars
Unaiza
Islamabad, Pakistan
Both the leaders should have come to a common conclusion. They did not think about the circumstances of the partition. Today both Pakistan and Bangladesh are unstable.
Add your Comment